Modern Day Reviews
Modern Day Reviews WE TEST SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO.
Tools & Home Improvement

Lutron Caséta Smart Switch Review

How the Lutron Caséta smart switch plus Pico remote gives you a 3-way setup without running new wire, and the neutral wire catch.

The Lutron Caséta smart switch is worth buying if you want a 3-way setup at a spot with no second switch wired in. The included Pico remote handles that side with zero new wiring. You do need a neutral wire at the existing switch box. Buy it.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Watch Our Review

How this review was made: written from my own video review of this product. Every opinion here is my own, from using it myself.

Wiring neededLine, load, neutral, ground
Second switch locationPico remote, no wiring
Mounting optionsDouble-sided adhesive or Pico wall plate
Smart home platformsAlexa, Google Home, HomeKit, SmartThings
BridgeLutron Smart Bridge, sold separately

The Hallway With No Switch At The Far End

Hey guys, it’s Eric, and the problem I’m solving here is the hallway with a switch at one end and nothing at the other. You always wanted one down there. You don’t want to open up drywall and run new wire. That’s exactly what this kit is for, and you can see the Lutron Caséta smart switch on Amazon to check the current price.

One switch gets wired. The other end gets a Pico remote stuck to the wall. Done. Lutron by far is the best smart switch out there on the market in my opinion, and this is the use case where it really separates itself from everything else.

No Neutral Wire: This One’s Out

You need a neutral wire in the one switch box that’s already wired. No neutral, no deal. That’s the gotcha, and I’d rather say it in the first 30 seconds than bury it.

Want the best Amazon finds in your inbox?

A short monthly email with the products I tested + actually liked. No spam.

Older homes are the ones that get burned here. If you pull the plate off and there’s no bundle of white wires in the back of the box, stop. Definitely look into their dimmer instead of their on-off switch, because those do not need neutral wires. Same line, same reliability, different wiring requirement.

The second thing people miss: the Lutron Smart Bridge is not in this kit. The switch and Pico talk to each other without it, but if you want Alexa, Google Home, HomeKit, or SmartThings in the picture, you’re buying the bridge too. Well worth getting, in my opinion, but budget for it.

Finding The Line Wire Is The Only Hard Part

Four connections: line, load, neutral, ground. Three of them are obvious. The one that isn’t is figuring out which black wire coming into the box is your line and which is your load, they look identical until you test them.

If you’re not sure, the easiest way is to undo everything, go back down to the panel, turn the power on, and test to see which one has power. Just be very, very safe doing that. Live wires in an open box deserve respect.

Once you know, it’s four connections. Line, load, neutral, ground. Tuck it all back in, make sure everything is nice and tight, put the plate on, and go turn the power back on. Then you pair it to your bridge, pull it into the Lutron app, and from there integrate it with whichever smart home platform you’re on.

The Pico remote gets set up in the same app. That’s the part that makes it a 3-way without any wiring at all.

Use The Wall Plate, Not The Sticky Pad

The Pico comes with double-sided adhesive on a little piece of plastic, and I’d skip it on its own. A bare Pico stuck to drywall looks like a bare Pico stuck to drywall.

The kit also includes the Lutron Pico Remote wall plate, which is the actual answer. Tape the Pico to the wall with the adhesive, screw the plate over the top, and it looks just like a real light switch. If you don’t want adhesive at all, you can screw the plate straight into the wall instead. You don’t have to, but the option’s there. Guests will press it without ever knowing it isn’t wired.

Why I Pay More For This Line

It costs more than most other smart switches, but delivers 100% uptime with zero delay, worth the premium for family installs. I’m not going to pretend otherwise.

The father-in-law test is why I landed here. Every other smart switch I’ve put in has had at least one moment, a half-second lag, a missed tap, a reboot-the-hub phone call. Caséta has never given me that moment. That’s not a feature you see on a spec sheet, but it’s the one that matters when the person on the other end of the phone isn’t going to open the Lutron app to diagnose anything.

Pricing on this kit moves enough that a number I type today will be wrong by next week. Check the current price on Amazon and factor in whether you still need the Smart Bridge, that’s the second purchase that catches people off guard.

As for which version to grab: the on-off switch is the one in this kit and it demands a neutral. The Caséta dimmer doesn’t. That’s the concrete difference that decides it for most older houses, not the feature list.

Pros

  • Creates a 3-way setup with zero new wiring, thanks to the included Pico remote
  • Works 100% of the time with no delay, which is why it’s the only line I’ll put in a family member’s house
  • Install is four connections once you identify the line wire
  • Pico wall plate makes the remote look like a real switch
  • Ties into Alexa, Google Home, HomeKit, and SmartThings through the Lutron app

Cons

  • Requires a neutral wire at the wired switch box, which rules out a lot of older homes
  • The Lutron Smart Bridge isn’t included and you need it for any smart home integration
  • More expensive than most other smart switches, bridge or no bridge
  • Finding the line wire means powering the box back up to test, which is the least fun part

What we’d improve

Two changes that would make this kit an easier recommendation:

  • No bridge in the box, the kit sells a smart home story it can’t finish on its own. A bundled bridge option would stop people from buying twice.
  • The bare adhesive mount, the double-sided pad on plastic is the lesser of the two mounting options and shouldn’t be the default presentation. Lead with the wall plate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a monthly fee for the Lutron app?

No subscription. You buy the switch and the bridge, and the Lutron app and platform integrations come with it. The ongoing cost is zero.

Does the Pico remote need batteries changed?

Yes, the Pico runs on a coin cell, not house power. That’s the trade for not running wire. Pop the plate off when it eventually needs swapping.

Will it still work if my internet goes down?

The switch and the Pico talk directly to each other, so the physical buttons keep working. What you lose is voice control and remote access through Alexa or HomeKit until the internet is back.

Can I add more Pico remotes to one switch?

Yes, you pair additional Picos in the Lutron app the same way you set up the first one. That’s how you turn a 3-way into a 4-way without touching a wire.

4.6
/5
★★★★½
Exceptional
Performance 5.0
Build Quality 4.6
Setup & Software 4.4
Value 4.2
Heavy use DIY Seniors
It loses ground only on cost and the separate bridge, because the switch itself responds with no delay every single time. Skip it if your box has no neutral, since the Caséta dimmer is the version you want instead. Put the bridge in the box and this is a flat five.
🛒 Get the best price on Amazon →

Clicking takes you to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases — pricing and availability subject to change.

Get it now

Lutron Caséta Smart Switch with Pico Remote

Get the best price on Amazon →

Affiliate link. See the disclosure at the top of this post.

🛍️ Shop everything in this video

Every product mentioned, in one place. These are affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

🛍️ Lutron Caseta Smart Switch: check price on Amazon →

🛍️ Lutron Caseta Bridge: check price on Amazon →

🛍️ Lutron Caseta Pico Remote: check price on Amazon →

🛍️ Lutron Caseta Pico Remote Wall Plate: check price on Amazon →

🛍️ Lutron Caseta Dimmer: check price on Amazon →

Leave a comment

Your email is required but never published. Be kind — first-time comments are held for review.

Marty, ModernDay’s Digital Editor from the Future

About us

Marty, ModernDay’s Digital Editor from the Future

We’re Amy and Eric, a husband-and-wife team reviewing products that make everyday life easier, smarter, and more fun. We test smart home tech, robot vacuums, pool cleaners, tools, gadgets, and everyday products in our own home. We handle the setup, confusion, trial and error, and frustrating moments so you know what to expect. We never do paid reviews. Brands may provide media samples, but they have no control or approval over our opinions. We share the good, the bad, and what brands may leave out to help you make smarter buying decisions.
Editors’ Pick

Reviewed in this post

Lutron Caséta Smart Switch Review

Get the best price on Amazon →
Verdict